Thursday Reads: Edward Snowden Becomes a Refugee in Russia


Good Morning!!

The news is breaking as I write this (around 8:15AM ET) that NSA leaker Edward Snowden has received papers that grant him refugee status in Russia for one year. From Reuters:

Fugitive former U.S. spy agency contractor Edward Snowden left Moscow’s Sheremetyevo airport on Thursday after Russiagranted him refugee status, ending more than a month in limbo in the transit area.

A lawyer who has been assisting Snowden said the young American, who is wanted in the United States for leaking details of secret government intelligence programs, had left the airport for a secure location which would remain secret….

His lawyer, Anatoly Kucherena, told state television: “I have just seen him off. He has left for a secure location … Security is a very serious matter for him.”

Lawyer Anatoly Kucherena holds Edward Snowden's entry papers from Russian Immigration Service

Lawyer Anatoly Kucherena holds Edward Snowden’s entry papers from Russian Immigration Service

So what will life in Russia be like for Snowden? A number of knowledgeable writers have weighed in on this question.

Last week, when rumors circulated that Snowden had been granted asylum and would soon leave Sheremetyevo, Russian-American journalist Julia Ioffe wrote in The New Republic that Snowden would probably

be given an apartment somewhere in the endless, soulless highrises with filthy stairwells that spread like fields around Moscow’s periphery. He will live there for five years before he will be given citizenship. He’ll likely be getting constant visits from the SVR (the Russian NSA) to mine the knowledge he carries in his brain. Maybe, he will be given a show on Russia Today, alongside the guy who got him into this pickle to begin with, Julian Assange. Or he, like repatriated Russian spy Anna Chapman, might be given a fake job at a state-friendly bank where he will do nothing but draw a salary. (Chapman, by the way, recently tweeted this at Snowden: “Snowden, will you marry me?!”) Maybe he will marry a Russian woman, who will quickly shed her supple, feminine skin and become a tyrant, and every dark winter morning, Snowden will sit in his tiny Moscow kitchen, drinking Nescafe while Svetlana cooks something greasy and tasteless, and he will sit staring into his black instant coffee, hating her.

Was it worth it to trade Hawaii and a pole-dancer girlfriend for that? Snowden will have plenty of time on his hands to think about it. He certainly won’t get a job in Russian intelligence. The Russians, at least, know you can’t trust a leaker even though he may be a convenient source of information.

Mark Ames, who lived in Russia for years and published and wrote for an alternative newspaper in Moscow with partner Matt Taibbi, recently wrote a short piece on Snowden’s future prospects at NSFWCORP with quotes from some Russian sources that I can no longer find on-line. Ames writes:

The latest on Edward Snowden from officials from the Federal Migration Service (FMS) say that Snowden could be transferred to a refugee center currently overflowing with Syrian war refugees, likely families tied to the Russian-backed regime of Bashir Assad. Or not.

Both Russian officials and Snowden’s Kremlin-tied lawyer are making a big show about how difficult the bureaucratic process is for anyone, even someone like Snowden, to get his temporary asylum papers. If you read the Russian press accounts, the surface statements about the Tsar’s alleged helplessness before the almighty bureaucracy are pure Gogol, without the ha-ha’s, a sort of no-laughter-through-tears. Beneath the surface, there’s something more menacing, a growing sense I get reading the Russian press that Snowden is a kind of Kremlin toy whom they’re intentionally fucking with, out of either contempt, or for the sheer fun of it…

Clearly, Russian President Vladimir Putin is having a blast sticking it to the US and soaking up praise from deluded Glenn Greenwald cultists (previously Obots) and Julian Assange fans who think Russia is a land of freedom and opportunity as in contrast to America, where jackbooted Obama administration thugs supposedly run a horrifying reign of terror.


Ames has a fascinating take on Snowden’s attorney’s bringing him a copy of Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment to read.

…the Kremlin gifting Snowden a copy of “Crime and Punishment” is itself a not-subtle mind-fuck on many levels. Dostoevsky’s book is a profoundly reactionary novel about a young foolish and desperate student full of second-hand radical ideas about his superiority against established morality. His name is Raskolnikov and he thinks he’s above ordinary human laws, so he kills his landlord according to these higher laws – and later goes crazy unable to believe in the radical ideas that led him to commit a crime, so he turns himself in to the authorities, and serves his time in Siberia as penance. The name of Dostoevsky’s hero, “Raskolnikov,” itself means “cracked” or “split” – as in his cracked conscience.

Last week Snowden’s lawyer, Anatoly Kucherena, told journalists…

“I bought [for Snowden] Dostoevsky’s ‘Crime and Punishment,’ because I think that Raskolnikov, who murdered his old landlord — I think that he needs to read about this. Not necessarily because of their similarities in their internal contradictions, but nevertheless…”

I loved this quote from opposition newspaper Novaya Gazeta (via Ames):

“Well, what can you say? If that infantile leftie Snowden really wanted to be a hero, he should return to the USA: crucify or not crucify, they’d probably give him 10 years, and he’d do five.”

“Snowden wanted to become a digital world’s Christ — without having to hang on the cross. Now Snowden’s going to spend not five years, but the rest of his life as a guest of the FSB.”

In another display of black humor, the Kremin website compared Snowden to British defectors and spies Kim Philby, Guy Burgess, and Don Maclean. In the posting the Kremlin notes that Philby and Burgess “drank themselves to death in their state-allocated flats, awaiting a world revolution that never came,” while Maclean got along better because he took the trouble to learn Russian. You can read more about Kim Philby at The Guardian. 

Russian refugee center

Russian refugee center

State supported newspaper Russia Today also speculated about Snowden’s future: Spook out of water: What Snowden can expect if Russia grants him asylum.

If the application is accepted and Snowden is given the 12-month temporary asylum that enables him to leave the transit area of Sheremetyevo airport, he will have to undergo a daunting medical assessment designed especially for immigrants. Along with a standard screening for HIV and tuberculosis, he will also be checked for leprosy and the rare sexually-transmitted disease chancroid. Russian Health Ministry officials have said that they are ready to administer the tests at a moment’s notice, but so far have not been asked to do so by Snowden.

After Snowden registers his whereabouts with the police – to avoid risking a $150 fine – he will be free to apply for placement in a processing facility for asylum seekers. There are no such facilities in Moscow, and ones in the vicinity have been flooded with refugees escaping the Syrian conflict. Elena Ryabinina, a human rights lawyer who works with asylum seekers, told newspaper that most of her clients get offered a bed in a center near Perm – a city by the Ural mountains, more than 1,000 km east of Moscow.

Sounds like tons of fun. But according to the article Snowden could choose to try to find a place on his own–but he’d have to get a bodyguard since he’s a “wanted man.”

Even if Snowden does acquire a personal bodyguard and a high security flat at an undisclosed location – presumably courtesy of the Russian state – his future is hazy, and the reality of it likely different to what he imagined when he recorded his first revelations.

A temporary asylum seeker is allowed to work, but not to put further strain on the testy relationship between Moscow and Washington. Vladimir Putin said “no longer undermining the US” is a pre-condition for his asylum bid, and the former NSA contractor publicly promised to comply when he met Russian human rights activists a fortnight ago. One wonders who it is that Snowden’s bodyguards will be protecting from danger.

Who knows if we’ll even find out what happens to Snowden now? All we can do is watch and wait. Something tells me he may eventually wish he had just come back home to face the music.

Yesterday, Glenn Greenwald posted another “bombshell” about a “top secret program” called XKEYSCORE. According to Greenwald, this “NSA tool collects ‘nearly everything a user does on the internet.'” I googled and learned that hundreds of companies are publicly advertising job openings for people with experience on XKEYSCORE–so how can it be so secret? I guess Greenwald didn’t bother to do a google search. He didn’t bother to talk to Marc Ambinder either. Ambinder wrote a whole book on US intelligence methods in which he described XKEYSCORE in detail. Can Greenwald actually be writing about these intel programs without reading any of the literature on them?

Ambinder writes in The Week:

I quibble with the Guardian‘s description of the program as “TOP SECRET.” The word is not secret; its association with the NSA is not secret; that the NSA collects bulk data on foreign targets is, well, probably classified, but at the SECRET level. Certainly, work product associated with XKEYSCORE is Top Secret with several added caveats. Just as the Guardian might be accused of over-hyping the clear and present danger associated with this particular program, critics will reflexively overstate the harm that its disclosure would reasonably produce.

XKEYSCORE is not a thing that DOES collecting; it’s a series of user interfaces, backend databases, servers and software that selects certain types of metadata that the NSA has ALREADY collected using other methods. XKEYSCORE, as D.B. Grady and I reported in our book, is the worldwide base level database for such metadata. XKEYSCORE is useful because it gets the “front end full take feeds” from the various NSA collection points around the world and importantly, knows what to do with it to make it responsive to search queries. As the presentation says, the stuff itself is collected by some entity called F6 and something else called FORNSAT and then something with the acronym SSO.

But Greenwald insisted on Chris Hayes show last night that XKEYSCORE does collect data–all your data–and someone creepy is probably reading it right now!!


In his piece at The Guardian Greenwald had to admit that NSA analysts need to get a warrant to look at and individual’s data, but he claims the warrants are worthless. He also admits that analysts don’t have access to all your personal data, but he says they could hack into it illegally. But isn’t that true for employees of any company or government agency? They could look at personal data by criminally working around limitations and ignoring regulations.

Charles Johnson at LGF: Greenwald’s Latest Article Distorts the Truth Again

Greenwald’s purpose with this latest article is to try to shore up Edward Snowden’s absurd claim that he could “wiretap anyone, even the President,” without any oversight. Here’s how he frames this defense:

The files shed light on one of Snowden’s most controversial statements, made in his first video interview published by the Guardian on June 10.

“I, sitting at my desk,” said Snowden, could “wiretap anyone, from you or your accountant, to a federal judge or even the president, if I had a personal email”.

US officials vehemently denied this specific claim. Mike Rogers, the Republican chairman of the House intelligence committee, said of Snowden’s assertion: “He’s lying. It’s impossible for him to do what he was saying he could do.”

But training materials for XKeyscore detail how analysts can use it and other systems to mine enormous agency databases by filling in a simple on-screen form giving only a broad justification for the search. The request is not reviewed by a court or any NSA personnel before it is processed.

Read this section carefully — because what Greenwald is detailing does not support Snowden’s claim at all. Greenwald is describing searching a database for information on non-US citizens. How is this the same thing as “wiretapping the President?” Of course, it’s not. He’s not describing any kind of “wiretapping” at all.

On top of all that, it turns out that the Powerpoint presentation that Greenwald wrote about yesterday is from 2008! (See slide pictured above.) Presumably much has changed at NSA since then. Read more at Joshua Foust’s blog–it’s well worth the time to read the whole thing.

Now it’s your turn. What stories are you focusing on today? Please share your links on any topic in the comment thread, and have a terrific Thursday!!

37 Comments on “Thursday Reads: Edward Snowden Becomes a Refugee in Russia”

  1. bostonboomer says:

    Have a great day everyone, and be glad you’re not in Siberia.

  2. bostonboomer says:

    Brad DeLong says Obama should pick Summers as Fed head.

  3. RalphB says:

    Greenwald is either one of the world’s biggest technological bozos or a huge freaking liar. Then again, maybe he’s both of those things.

    Chris Hayes has proven to be a major credulous dumbass over all this like a naive child. His credibility is in the toilet, as far as I’m concerned.

    • bostonboomer says:

      I used to think Hayes was good on weekends, but he can’t carry 5 nights a week.

      • RalphB says:

        He certainly can’t and that’s been really disappointing. The “brogressive” outlook is beginning to hack me off.

        • bostonboomer says:

          I really miss Ed Shultz, and I wasn’t always that big a fan. But he projects a lot of energy and focuses on middle- and working-class issues.

          • Fannie says:

            As it turned out, I too miss Ed…………and I see him on Saturday, on occasion.

          • RalphB says:

            I miss him to and look forward to his weekend shows.

          • Ed always struck me as phony…but I can see what you mean, target issues wise. I would love to see a more concentrated middle and working class focus anywhere on the airwaves…

            Actually I’d just love a Liz Warren station/channel 😉

  4. bostonboomer says:

    A year ago, Glenn Greenwald wrote a column chiding any American who dares to criticize the human rights records of Russia and Ecuador, because our government also has human rights issues.

    • RalphB says:

      That was the kind of stupid crap that turned me away from the Blame America First crowd.

  5. bostonboomer says:
  6. RalphB says:

    I sure hope PPP is as accurate in 2014 as they were in 2012.

    Poll: Kentucky Voters Want McConnell Out

    New poll numbers released Thursday suggested that Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) is entering his reelection campaign next year facing two perilous obstacles: an electorate that wants him out of office and a viable Democratic challenger.

  7. bostonboomer says:

    Apparently, Snowden has been offered a job at the Russian version of Facebook.

    Bad google translation:

    Snowden was invited to work in the “VKontakte”

    Snowden, a year granted asylum in Russia, most likely, will not remain without work. CEO of the social network “VKontakte” Pavel Durov offered ex-CIA employee to work the programmer.

    “We invite Edward to St. Petersburg and will be happy if he decides to fill up a stellar team of programmers” VKontakte. “In the end, there is no more popular European Internet companies than VK. Think Edward might be interesting deal with the protection of personal data of millions of our people,” – Durov wrote on his page in the social network.

    He also called Snowden whistleblower “crimes against the citizens of the U.S. intelligence services around the world.” “At such moments, you feel proud of our country and regretted the policy of the U.S. – a country committed to the principles upon which it was built once,” – said Pavel Durov.

    • bostonboomer says:

      Snowden leaving airport surrounded by FSB agents

    • Fannie says:

      Would that Russian website be BULLSHITSKY?

    • Oh, he will fit in perfectly with that crowd…

      I just woke up, spent all night watching Top of the Lake, all 7 episodes at once. Didn’t get to sleep until after 6am…what a Myshkin I am!

    • peej says:

      Yo, BB. I’m determined to make today my catch-up day. I’m running behind in reading the latest posts. Please forgive my delay. You know how much I enjoy Snowden updates. This is a great one, thank you!

      I love the gift of Crime and Punishment! That has to be the hoot of the week!

      I’m wagering that Snowden’s primary job will be consultant for the establishment of the BRICS Bank and the BRICS Virtual Secretariat – using the NSA blueprint, of course. I think both are scheduled to be up and running by 2015, but I’m not sure about that. Have to confirm the target dates.

      I wouldn’t doubt that in the mean time (if he hasn’t already done so online) he’ll take up the formal invitations from North Korea and Brazil to visit with the purpose of discussing American cyber-security and counter-espionage systems. If he did, it would put any future, formal charge of treason in another light wouldn’t it? And at this point, Russia has succeeded in forcing what seems to be a non-existant threat – the threat of the death penalty for Snowden. But if Snowden did speak with North Korean and Brazilian governments at their own behests under the current cloud of transparency, why that would complicate charges of treason further, wouldn’t it? Putin has succeeded in forcing the US to concede that it won’t seek the death penalty in the future. All very odd to me. I think both the US and Russia know perfectly well but can’t at this juncture admit in the public arena that Snowden’s crimes may very well exceed espionage and warrant an undeniable charge of treason. Certainly, if Snowden is assisting Russia not with its social media, but with a Virtual Secretariat, then a charge of treason would likely be inevitable.

      The Virtual Secretariat appears to be the administrative superstructure for the entire BRICS operation whose intended goal, of course, is to shift the balance of global economic power from West to East – to the BRICS alliance. It would seem to me that NSA capabilities pose the most serious obstacle to its success. Might it not be to their great advantage for NSA’s cyber-security to be slowed down by its own gears, gummed up, severely curtailed, or virtually eliminated? Excuse the pun. Better yet – to have their opponent’s cyber-security blueprint right in front of them as they design the foundations of their own?

      The BRICS initiative defines itself in terms of global governance and while it may not be as far along in its institutional structure as a similar alliance like the EU – it would seem that what will get BRICS to that institutional model is the Virtual Secretariat.

      Here’s a report about BRICS heading into their Durban Summit – about the same time that Snowden was making his first contact with the media:

      The Delhi Declaration which came out of the 2012 summit:

      I’m not attempting to demonize the BRICS effort at all by bringing this up. Rather to draw attention to its legitimacy. By the looks of it, BRICS really has its five fingers on the pulse of global governance and global economics. A side note on that – I believe Russia recently imposed restrictions on its elected officials in using off-shore accounts – like in Cyprus. In other words, to do what the Mitt Romneys and Western supranational financial elites do at the expense of their “host” countries – and let’s not miss the implication there – as in the host who is drained of all life by its supranational financier parasites.

      Bottom line is this: The “blueprint of the NSA” would have immeasurable utility in the context of establishing a Virtual Secretariat. But for the purposes of leaking to the media, the necessity of the entire blueprint makes no sense at all. Snowden’s justification for physically taking this tremendous amount of info as proof to back his claims doesn’t make any sense given Greenwald’s puerile handling of it. His XKeyscore “revelation” seems to underscore this point. And really, if Greenwald did handle it with more sophistication, from a journalism perspective, the superfluous material isn’t necessary for establishing Snowden’s claims as credible.

      At any rate, my money is Snowden isn’t working on a social media platform, he’s working on the Virtual Secretariat.

  8. RalphB says:

    A good one has passed on… R.I.P. Doghouse Riley

  9. bostonboomer says:

    Ohio kidnap victims tell Ariel Castro he will ‘face hell for eternity’

    • But Castro has no remorse, Cleveland abductor Castro defiant as he gets life in prison | Reuters

      Ariel Castro, 53, apologized to his victims, but was mostly defiant, verbally sparring with the judge during a court hearing as he sought to blame his actions on a sexual obsession and having been abused as a child.

      “I am not a monster,” he told the court in a rambling statement before sentencing.

      The women, along with a 6-year-old girl Castro fathered, were rescued from his fortress-like house on May 6, after 9 to 11 years of captivity.

      “If you asked my daughter, she would say, ‘My dad is the best dad in the world’,” Castro said.

      “All the sex was consensual,” he told the judge. “The girls were not virgins. They had multiple sex partners before me.”

      I wish they would just stick him in with the General Population and give the prison system a chance to serve its own form of justice…and let the other prisoners sort it out.

    • Knight was incredibly brave.

  10. Fannie says:

    Did you see this – Couple days ago Obama gave a speech on his Jobs Plan, and this decided to talk out of his arse: