Monday Reads

Good Morning!

Bjy32YbCYAAE11RI’m going to remind you today of some events that happened 4 years ago with the BP Oil Gusher and show you that bad things are still going on in the Gulf.The leftover issues from abandoned oil rigs are bigger than Louisiana.Please consider this an open thread while I let you know how I feel.

If corporations are people, then BP and others in the extraction business are serial killers.    All over our country and throughout our history, extraction companies have killed their employees, the people that live around their businesses, and the wildlife and the environment and water systems that sustain the life of our country.  Look at that map.  Those are active and orphaned/abandoned oil wells/pipelines that are disintegrating, leaking, and killing someone.

“I started noticing, towards the end of 2010, other leaks that were unrelated to the BP disaster,” Henderson says. “I would find wellheads that were leaking or platforms that were leaking. Just in the last year, I have filed 50 reports for different leaks and spills unrelated to the BP disaster.”

Under the Clean Water Act, when a company spills any amount of oil in the water, it must file a report with the National Response Center run by the Coast Guard. But when Henderson checked, he found many of those smaller spills were not making that list.

So environmental groups formed the Gulf Monitoring Consortium to get a better count on spills. The partnership is a blend groups of complementary skills.

Gulf Restoration Network, for example, has personnel who can spot spills from the air and file complete reports.

SouthWings, a group of volunteer pilots, helps get those spotters aloft.

Louisiana relies largely on the oil industry to self-report leaks and spills. The Gulf Monitoring Consortium was formed to improve that effort and said it often finds smaller leaks like this one, near Golden Meadow, that go unreported by the companies.

A third member, the West Virginia-based tech group SkyTruth, finds the spills on satellite photographs, then applies a formula used by spill experts to translate the size of the oil sheen into gallons of oil in the water.

SkyTruth spokesman David Manthos says its estimates typically are much higher than what’s been reported.

“We found that the spill was usually 10 times larger than had been reported, and that was averaged out across a lot,” he says. “In some, the mismatch was much larger than that.”

The sheer size of the industry here means there’s seldom a quiet day for the consortium. In an average year, the NRC receives 10,000 reports of spills in the Gulf.

It’s a number that surprised even SouthWings Gulf Program Director Meredith Dowling, a veteran of monitoring efforts.

“I can’t think of a single instance where our volunteers have flown offshore and not found spills,” Dowling says. “This was something that was really amazing to me when I first moved here … that is was a continuous, absolute failure of business-as-usual practices.”

There are many active spills around here.  Many come from orphaned and abandoned wells.  Many come from active wells.  They are all spewing toxicil_570xN.378041774_q0qdwaste and it’s not just in Louisiana.  Here is a program in Pennsylvania dedicated to plugging orphaned and abandoned wells.  There are similar issues in Texas, New York State, and just nearly anywhere there’s been activity.  Louisiana alone has about 6000.   You can see that they are nearly everywhere if you look at the map at the top of the post.  Many of these  wells were first put into play in the 1850s and were just left where they were.  They are rotting, they are decaying, and they are leaking.  They are also dangerous. 

Methane is an odorless, colorless gas that exists naturally below the surface. It isn’t poisonous, but it’s dangerous. When enough methane gathers in an enclosed space — a basement or a water well, for instance — it can trigger an explosion.

The gas didn’t come from the Butters well, nor did it originate from the Marcellus Shale formation that a nearby Shell well had recently tapped into. What most likely happened to cause the geyser in June, Shell and state regulators say, was something of a chain reaction.  As Shell was drilling and then hydraulically fracturing its nearby well, the activity displaced shallow pockets of natural gas — possibly some of the same pockets the Morris Run Coal company ran into  in 1932. The gas disturbed by Shell’s drilling moved underground until it found its way to the Butters well, and then shot up to the surface.

Areas impacted by oil spills are never the same. The BP Oil Gusher has introduced issues into the ecosystem that have left endangered species teetering further towards extinction.  In the case of Louisiana, it’s even the state bird.

On a bright spring morning, P.J. Hahn is walking through a graveyard in the middle of Barataria Bay.

It’s a 30-yard patch of mud and sand bristling with bare, dead mangrove brush surrounded by miles of open water. Each mangrove is a tombstone marking the death of a nesting site used for decades by brown pelicans and roseate spoonbills on what was once the string of wetland pearls that made up the Cat Islands chain.

But in 2010 the oil spewing from BP’s Deepwater Horizon would send them all to an early grave.

“Four years ago we had more than five acres of habitat and there were tens of thousands of birds nesting on these islands,” said Hahn, director of coastal zone management for Plaquemines Parish. “Then the oil came in and coated the mangrove roots, and two years later the islands started going.

“I don’t know where those birds are nesting now – but they can’t do it here any more.”

The post-BP story of the brown pelican, Louisiana’s official bird, is the perfect metaphor for the crisis confronting the state’s coast.

Before the Deepwater Horizon blew out on April 20, 2010, brown pelicans were living the good life in southeast Louisiana as one of the great wildlife comeback stories. In 1963 not a single brown pelican could be found in the state due to impacts from the insectiside DDT.  The comeback started in 1968 when the state began transplanting birds from Florida, and populations began to soar after DDT was banned in 1972. Thanks to the abundant food in one of the world’s most productive fisheries, by 2010 their numbers were thought to be near historic levels, as high of 85,000.*

il_570xN.369622702_4p2jFour years later, the sea floor closest to the spill and even the shores in the Gulf of Mexico are  comparable to an Arizona Desert. It is barren, bleak and dead.  There was life there.  Now, there is the look of a forest fire without the resultant new growth.  Nothing will grow back amid the poison of Corexit and Oil.

When a crew of journalists and environmental groups studying the effects of the BP Deepwater Macondo oil spill disembarked on Cat Island in Baratria Bay last week, there was a collective gasp.

“It looks like the Arizona desert,” said Eileen Fleming, who’s reported for WWNO spring after spring since the April 20, 2010 spill.

“It looks like there was a fire here,” said Doug Meffert, vice president of the National Audubon Society and president of the Louisiana chapter, “but there wasn’t a fire.”

The bones of black mangrove stumps are all that remain of what was a thriving bird rookery here in Plaquemines Parish Four years ago, footage of oiled brown pelicans and the thousands of shorebirds nesting here went around the world in the aftermath of the 200 million gallons of thick crude that spilled into the Gulf of Mexico.

Today the only green thing on the beach is a glass bottle. There are no pelicans, no mangroves, and worse, much of Cat Island itself is washing away. It and most of the barrier islands and marsh in Barataria Bay are steadily degrading, losing their battles with coastal erosion and subsidence faster than ever.

The NIH is still studying some of the direct health impacts of both the oil and the toxic Corexit used to hide the extent of the spill.

Areas around Barataria Bay and Grand Isle, La. were particularly hard hit, but they weren’t the only affected areas. Moreover, thousands of birds, other wildlife and marine life including dolphins perished, were oiled, sickened and overall left in distress. The effects on the area resonate now, which is only a shock to those either unfamiliar with garish oil spills or unwilling to accept the truth.

In the days following the “spill”, BP, apparently colluding with the US Government, doused a horrific amount of a deadly dispersant in the affected areas. Called “Corexit”, the cutesy name belies the sickening effects it brings to all it touches. On background, an environmentalist working in the area explained to me last year that they were, essentially, damned if they did, and damned if they didn’t, but chose the lesser of two ills.

That remains to be seen as the National Institutes of Health continues its 10-year “GuLF” study of BP spill health effects, from those most affected out on the Vessels of Opportunity boat that included BP-hired personnel trying to contain the spill, to residents in the line of fire, such as around Barataria Bay.

There is a way of life dying along the southern parts of the Gulf Coast in Louisana.  The coastline disappears daily, the salt water intrudes in to the fresh il_570xN.382956444_9et2water marshes, and the land doesn’t sustain the people or the animals like it once did.  There is not better place to study the impacts of the extraction business and human addiction to fossil fuels than many parts of Cajun Louisiana.

Sea level rise is like an ultra-slow-motion hurricane for low-lying areas, but unlike a hurricane, it can be forecast decades in advance. Projections that some town or road will be underwater in 100 years can—and must—be mitigated against today.

Osborn characterizes the choice as “being proactive rather than reactive. Once you get into situations like Louisiana facing some very serious challenges in a very near time frame, all of a sudden you’re in a reactive posture.” Louisiana is a harbinger of things to come for New York, Miami, and other major coastal cities that would do well to look 20 to 75 years ahead and budget accordingly. Local, state, and federal governments will have to make critical decisions about infrastructure, water and sediment diversion, and wetlands restoration in the next 10 to 15 years, he says, and while NOAA scientists can contribute data, they can’t green-light projects or secure funding.

Osborn makes a technical distinction: “Right now it’s what’s called frequently flooded. And the risk is it will be routinely flooded.” Routine flooding will start to happen as early as 10 years from now, he says. They can call it whatever they want, but Gill says soon LA 1 will be “flooded every day during high tide.”

NOAA scientists predict that eventually all the marsh that surrounds LA 1 and Port Fourchon will disappear, connecting two major bodies of water that now are distinct: Barataria Bay and Terrebonne Bay. The only thing out in the water at all, by 2100, may be a raised road and Port Fourchon. “I can imagine Port Fourchon being like the Florida Keys,” says Chiasson, “being on its own, in the middle of open water, maybe a little marsh around it, but nothing between here and there.”

The fact that the entire extraction business is so fraught with so many bad things is why the men that run it must find politicians to protect them from lawsuits and regulations.  Making these guys pay for what they’ve done would undoubtedly run their companies deeply into the red. Donation whores like Republican Governor Bobby Jindal will do anything to protect the benefactors that he hopes will fund him to the White House. There is nothing about Louisiana that this man is interested in except as a step on the rung of his personal ascent.

The state Senate targeted the flood protection authorities around New Orleans and the lawsuit one of the levee boards filed against the oil and gas industry for damages to the state’s wetlands.

In one bill, advanced by a Senate panel Wednesday morning, Gov. Bobby Jindal would get sweeping power to remove members of the Southeast Louisiana Flood Protection Authorities. Opponents said the move, which would allow a governor to remove authority members under certain conditions, reintroduces politics into the levee boards, which is precisely what revamp after the 2005 hurricanes was designed to prevent.

Another measure, which was passed by the full Senate late Tuesday night, would derail a lawsuit filed last year by the Southeast Louisiana Flood Protection Authority — East against 97 oil and gas companies. The levee board sought damages for contributing to coastal erosion and led to higher than anticipated storm surges.

Jindal opposes the lawsuit and has called it a windfall for lawyers, who would be paid with a portion of any winnings rather than a flat fee. Critics say the legislation would keep the oil and gas industry from taking responsibility for damage caused by drilling and productions activities over the years.

SB553 is aimed at a lawsuit filed by the Southeast Louisiana Flood Protection Authority-East. It would not impact similar suits filed by Jefferson and Plaquemines Parishes. But other measures currently being considered might.

The legislation passed Tuesday night, Senate Bill 553, would apply to retroactively. That measure was sent Wednesday morning to the Louisiana House.

Even kindergartners know they should clean up their messes.  That is ones that aren’t sociopaths.

But, wherever there has been the extraction business, there are the sociopaths.  We have the hundred year anniversary of just such an example.

Linda Linville climbed down the steep stone steps into the dugout on the southern Colorado prairie Sunday where one branch of her family was wiped out in one day 100 years ago.

Her great aunt, her unborn baby and two children died in a fire that broke out during a battle between coal miners striking against John D. Rockefeller, Jr. and the Colorado National Guard in what became known as the Ludlow Massacre. Twenty-seven-year-old Cedilena Costa, 4-year-old Lucy and 6-year-old Onofrio suffocated from the smoke as they hid below ground to escape the battle. Linville said Cedilena’s husband, Charlie Costa, was captured and shot in the head that day and never knew his family’s fate.

“Anyone who says they died in vain is wrong,” said Linville, a retired history teacher from Corona, Calif., referring to the fact that the miners eventually ended up going back to work without winning any of their demands.

The massacre and battle left 21 people dead, including the Greek-American union leader Louis Tikas, and set off 10 days of civil war in which the miners killed 30 mine guards, supervisors and strikebreakers. They surrendered only after President Woodrow Wilson sent federal troops to the state.

The deaths drew national attention to the long running strike and forced Rockefeller to take a public role in Colorado Fuel & Iron. He instituted a company union and grievance system, which the miners later rejected when the won a right to unionize on their own during the New Deal. The massacre and the deadly Triangle Shirtwaist fire in 1911 are credited with the helping win the eventual passage of the 1935 National Labor Relations Act.

Linville and over 100 others — including members of the United Mine Workers of America wearing the red bandanas the strikers wore — gathered at the site of the former Ludlow tent colony to mark the massacre’s 100th anniversary with a Greek Orthodox Easter service. It was very similar to the one the miners, who came from a variety of countries, shared in 100 years ago with the Greek strikers the day before the massacre. In a coincidental reminder of Ludlow’s international community, the Easter service will include the traditional reading of the Gospel story in many languages to symbolize the universality of its message.

It is easy to look back at the years of coal and oil and see that not much has really changed in terms of the business.  The only thing that’s changing is that people, nature, and animals don’t have a chance at all and the deathtoll and damage are obvious if you actually get to see it.  I have a small car.  I really don’t drive much at all.  I think in a busy week I may put on 15 miles.   I have a bike and nearly everything I need is about a mile away. I suppose, for me, that it’s nothing to say that I really don’t benefit from any of this.  I’d frankly rather pay for every single person to have some form of solar or wind generator in their home than the tax breaks we give to the oil industry.  I think it would save every one in the country a lot less grief in the short and long run.  But then, I could care less how much money the likes of the Koch Brothers earn.  I’d frankly rather be dancing on their graves.

I just wanted to add that I found some of  these wonderful skull art prints from this site. 

I know it doesn’t look like it, but this is an open thread.

What’s on your reading and blogging list today?

46 Comments on “Monday Reads”

  1. bostonboomer says:

    Excellent though very sad post. I shouldn’t be shocked to learn that there are so many oil spills that don’t get publicized, but I really am shocked. Thank you for keeping us up to date on the happenings down your way.

    • RalphB says:

      I’m not shocked there are so many leaking wells and I doubt they are close to finding them all even now. On thing less mentioned is air quality, which is swiftly going to hell where they are fracking the shale formations in Texas. It’s getting frequently dangerous to breath, let alone drink the water.

      • dakinikat says:

        From what I’ve read, Texas is the only state that really does a good job at that. The rest of the states are really hit and miss.

        • RalphB says:

          There have been so many wells drilled and abandoned in Texas that, if they didn’t do a decent job of it, we’d be drowning in leaked oil by now. Now if the GOP government would just do half as well as the old Democrats did, the fracking problems could be handled.

    • dakinikat says:

      I have to say that the great hero in this area these days is general Russell Honore. I swear I would go to battle with that man. He is just fearless in this area. I can imagine jindal hates him.

      • dakinikat says:

        The vote favored oil and gas companies, as expected. The trade groups representing the business community were thrilled. But not everyone is OK with changing the rules to favor one side after the game starts. Moments later, Russel Honoré, the U.S. Army general who restored order in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina, posted on his Facebook page that Gov. Bobby Jindal distributed checks to buy votes, “all in name to get big oil money so he can run for White House. Sad face.”

        Jindal’s aides usually belittle anyone who raises even the mildest question about the governor’s positions. But this is the “Hero of New Orleans,” the no-nonsense soldier over whom politicians fawn. Jindal’s aides remained quiet, confining their attacks to reporters who asked the governor for a response.

        “I was being metaphorical,” Honoré said Wednesday.

        “When you call the boys up before a big vote, they get something. … They get a bill they want done. They get a bridge. They get something. This thing has the governor’s hand all over.”

        Honoré and the flood authority argue, generally, that the energy industry cut canals through marshes in pursuit of oil and natural gas. In the permits, the 97 companies sued agreed to repair the damage, but they didn’t, which allowed salt water to intrude and kill off vegetation needed to slow hurricane storm surges, the lawsuit says.

        The oil and gas industry counters, and Jindal agrees, that back in the day they cleaned up their messes to the level required by the state.

        It’s unfair to now hold them accountable for actions that state officials once approved.

        “That’s why the courts need to get involved,” Honoré said. A judge and jury can sort out the information, see how the evidence fits a given situation and come up with a fair solution.

        “Look, the reason we have so many lawsuits in this state is because we don’t have enough laws. When you break someone’s stuff … you should be held responsible. But they can say, ‘No, no, I don’t have to pay for it because it’s permitted under state law.’ ”

        Having a strong regulatory system would set the boundaries in advance. Corporations invest in stable environments where they know the rules going in and know the rules won’t change down the road, Honoré said.

      • RalphB says:

        The reason Texas did a decent job of regulating oil companies when Democrats ran the state is because, even if there was corruption, there were competing interests. Oil and other business groups on one side with trial lawyers usually on the other and both sides held sway with large groups of the Democrats in power, so things evened out. When the GOP took over, the trial lawyers largely lost their voice and the business interests now have no competition so the assholes get what they want in most cases. Even in corruption, it’s good to have competition in the marketplace!

      • Fannie says:

        I will never forget the day I saw Russell Honore in New Orleans. I just broke down. I hope he never goes away.

  2. bostonboomer says:

    For Dakinikat:

    Chrystia Freeland (author of Plutocrats) reviews the new book by Thomas Picketty

    The Book Every Plutocrat Should Read

  3. joanelle says:

    Well, I don’t see it as “a sense of persecution” I view it as a slight bit of guilt, but they don’t know what it is recognizing emotions is out of their skill set.
    They don’t seem to understand that pay equality would actually boost the economy by reducing dependency on welfare, food stamps, etc. and help their businesses by creating better morale. Unfortunately their prejudices won’t allow them to think logically.

    • dakinikat says:

      I think some of them realize they’ve basically won a lottery rather than having risen to the top from some aspect of specialness. Otherwise, they wouldn’t be so damned insecure about things. Some of them do earn their pay. Most of them either inherit it or just are very good at climbing on other people to the top.

  4. joanelle says:

    Thanks for this excellent post Kat, but BB’s right, it is sad and depressing.

  5. bostonboomer says:

    Justice Scalia tells student if taxes go too high people “should revolt.”

    Isn’t that sedition or something?

  6. bostonboomer says:

    NBC did a psychological assessment of David Gregory to figure out why Meet the Press is doing so badly.

    Last year, the network undertook an unusual assessment of the 43-year-old journalist, commissioning a psychological consultant to interview his friends and even his wife. The idea, according to a network spokeswoman, Meghan Pianta, was “to get perspective and insight from people who know him best.” But the research project struck some at NBC as odd, given that Gregory has been employed there for nearly 20 years.

  7. dakinikat says:

    Why Republican Donors and Voters Don’t Get Along Even as Democrats attack Republicans for catering to the wealthy, the GOP base is distinctly working-class.

    • RalphB says:

      We’re talking about a group of folks who see Democratic efforts at gun control as a cultural assault, an attack on their values.

      So we’re talking about a group of insecure assholes who think keeping firearms out of the hands of violent felons and the mentally ill is an attack on them. Well, they know themselves better than I do.

      • dakinikat says:

        Utah boy, 2, shot and killed by 3-year-old sister

        let’s add this one to the list of that ‘cultural assault”

        • RalphB says:

          Raw Story: Road-raging Texas driver shoots 3-year-old girl on Easter

          Police in South Houston are searching for a suspect who was accused of shooting a 3-year-old girl in what was thought to be a case of drunken road rage.

          “The suspect’s vehicle pulled up right next to them, started firing shots into the rear window of the vehicle,” Gilbert noted. “On the passenger’s side of the rear, there was a 3-year-old in a car seat. Apparently one of the bullets grazed the right leg of that 3-year-old.”

          Ignoring the red light, the father sped off and stopped at nearby relative’s apartment to call the police. Leah was reportedly in stable condition after being taken to Bayshore Hospital.

          Another for the list. This shit has to be ended!

        • Fannie says:

          These parents need to be charged with manslaughter, and never be allowed to own guns. They go to bed every night with their bible and their NRA Card next to them.

  8. bostonboomer says:

    For the first time in 31 years, An American won the men’s title at the Boston Marathon.

    Meb Keflezighi wins Boston Marathon; women’s winner sets course record

  9. NW Luna says:

    Well-written and thoroughly referenced post, kat, on how the greedheads in the extraction business, especially oil, make their workers, people in the community, and the environment pay and suffer while they get rich off the extraction.

    In my area it’s the logging –err, timber companies. The Oso mudslide was a sequelae of extraction logging while trashing the land, scalping over the assigned borders, and sloppy — or no — cleanup, while regulators looked the other way.

    We need some trust-busters and Teddy Roosevelts again.

  10. dakinikat says:

    These Americans Are Fighting for an Actual, Legitimate Democracy, By and For the People
    U.S. democracy is illegitimate. Time for the American Awakening.

  11. dakinikat says:

    EPA Gives BP ‘Get Out of Jail Free Card’ on 4th Anniversary of Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Disaster

  12. RalphB says:


  13. RalphB says:

  14. RalphB says:

    Burning Man to BUNDYFEST. This is a hilarious video……