Sky Dancing

a place to discuss real issues

Live Blog: Fox News’ Second Tier GOP Candidates Debate

happy hour debate

Fox News is calling the warm-up debate among the Republican presidential candidates who have poll numbers from around zero to three percent the “Happy Hour debate.” It begins at 5PM Eastern, and the participants will be Rick Perry, Rick Santorum, Bobby Jindal, Carly Fiorina, George Pataki, Lindsey Graham, and Jim Gilmore.

‘Happy hour’ debate holds big potential for GOP ‘underdog’ to shine.

It’s been called the “happy hour” debate — the 5 p.m. face-off that precedes the prime-time showdown among the top-polling Republican presidential candidates in Cleveland.

But the stakes for those invited to “happy hour” could be even higher.

Seven lower-polling candidates were invited to the 5 p.m. ET Fox News/Facebook debate stage. The smaller pond, it’s an opportunity for at least one of the candidates to make a big splash — and start the buzz that builds a fledgling bid into a serious campaign.

“An underdog is going to emerge from this first debate,” Craig Shirley, a conservative strategist and Reagan biographer, said.

Texas Gov. Rick Perry, who flamed out of the 2012 race after an infamous debate gaffe, is looking for redemption. Former New York Gov. George Pataki, even though he won’t be on the big stage with Donald Trump, appears poised to hammer the billionaire front-runner. Former HP exec Carly Fiorina has been blunt in saying that, as the only woman in the field, she would be a potent adversary against Democratic front-runner Hillary Clinton.

Any of the seven could have a break-out moment Thursday afternoon that catapults them into the upper mix of the 17 candidates now on the field.

I don’t know. It’s hard to imagine any of those losers breaking through. But another conflict could be between Rick Santorum and Lindsey Graham over this claim from Santorum:

Santorum told Fox News on Thursday he plans to just be “authentic.”

“I did this 22 times the last time around,” said the former presidential candidate.

He said he’ll be able to stand out by pointing to his legislative record as a former senator, fighting to ban partial-birth abortions, enact welfare reform and impose Iran sanctions.

“They’re really isn’t anybody else up there on the stage who has a record of accomplishment in Washington, D.C.,” he said.

Graham has been in Congress a lot longer than Santorum was. He must have a few accomplishments.

I hope I’m not going to be alone in watching this thing. If you’re doing so, please share your observations in the comment thread below.

I’ll put up a separate post for the 9:00 main event.

Comments

96 responses to “Live Blog: Fox News’ Second Tier GOP Candidates Debate”

  1. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    First question for Bobby JIndal: since you’re so unpopular in Louisiana, why should voters nationwide trust you?

    He ignored the question and talked about how he cut taxes, and bla bla bla . . .

    1. dakinikat Avatar

      Is there any one in the audience?

    2. JJ Lopez Minkoff Avatar

      Wait huh? I am going nuts. This is not the real fucking debate? Help me Obi BB Won….I’ve read this happy hour thing twice and I still don’t get it. What the fuck is this?

  2. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Jim Gilmore is up. Who????

    I guess he used to be Gov. of VA.

    1. bostonboomer Avatar
      bostonboomer

      He’s reciting his resume. Boy is he booooorrrrrrinnnngggg!

    2. Fannie Avatar
      Fannie

      Yes, the only one who has foreign experience.

  3. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Question for Rick Perry about Donald Trump. Perry explains that Trump is just playing on his celebrity–he’s not even a conservative.

  4. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Others are asked to weigh in on Trump.

    1. bostonboomer Avatar
      bostonboomer

      Fiorina brings up the call from Bill Clinton and Trump’s donations to the Clinton Foundation. Says he’s changed his mind on all the big GOP issues. What are his actually principles?

  5. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    How will you deal with ISIS, Bobby Jindal?

    1. bostonboomer Avatar
      bostonboomer

      Jindal says we need to kill these evil terrorists and stopping beating around the bush about what we call them, like Jindal says Obama does.

    2. bostonboomer Avatar
      bostonboomer

      Graham says we have to have ground forces in Iraq and Syria. The air campaign won’t work.

      1. bostonboomer Avatar
        bostonboomer

        Oh, and he opened by saying if we don’t defeat them over there they’ll come here. And we have to fight them as long as it takes no matter what the cost.

        They’re coming here? Why do we have a department of “homeland security” then? What are the FBI and CIA doing? Should all those folks just be fired?

      2. Fannie Avatar
        Fannie

        Hey, he’s a hating Hillary Clinton’s guts. Put boots on the ground till the end of time.
        Happy, Happy, Happy, is not so Happy after all.

    3. dakinikat Avatar

      shhhh! he’s hunting tewwowists

      1. ANonOMouse Avatar
        ANonOMouse

        Did Graham look like a nervous wreck or what?

        1. dakinikat Avatar

          They all looked nonplussed to me. It was like, hey I’m a big deal, why I am here during the cocktail hour talking to no one?

  6. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Commercial break.

    Come on guys! Don’t tell me no one else is watching these losers.

    1. Fannie Avatar
      Fannie

      I am, I was wondering when Jindal said something of Sunni’s, like we have some kind of treaty with them. I don’t think so.

  7. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    More questions about ISIS. This time for Pataki. Obama doesn’t want to call these people here who sympathize “Islamic extremists.” What will you do?

  8. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Lots of tough talk from Pataki. I’m not going to transcribe it. Ugh. Oh, he does say they will attack us here if we don’t get them over there. We do have to put troops on the ground he says.

    1. Fannie Avatar
      Fannie

      Yeah, he’s in, he’s out. He’s yes and he’s no.

  9. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Question for Fiorina on homegrown terrorists.

    1. bostonboomer Avatar
      bostonboomer

      She says we have to make sure dots are connected when we have warnings–e.g., there were warnings about the Boston Marathon attacks.

      Really?

      1. bostonboomer Avatar
        bostonboomer

        More collaboration is needed between the government and private companies like Google.

      2. ANonOMouse Avatar
        ANonOMouse

        Fiorina couldn’t even connect the Dots at HP. And that smile of hers made me cover my eyes. I think I noticed the look of plastic surgery.

    2. Fannie Avatar
      Fannie

      Fiorina, well here is what to do, take your hands and twirl them on both sides of your head. That about say it all.

      1. bostonboomer Avatar
        bostonboomer

        ROFLOL! Thanks for showing up, Fannie. Now I don’t feel so alone.

  10. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Rick Santorum answers a question about immigration. His grandfather was stuck in fascist Italy for years, separated from his family. But his grandfather didn’t resent it. He believed in following the law. “America was worth the wait,” he supposedly said.

    1. ANonOMouse Avatar
      ANonOMouse

      That was the biggest BS comment of the debate.

  11. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Rick: 35 million that comes to this country are unskilled workers. Fucking liar.

  12. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    What do you say to the families of illegals, Rick Perry?

    Perry says Americans are sick and tired of this question. Americans will never trust Washington DC because we don’t secure the borders. Perry says he is the one with the experience to deal with this issue.

  13. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Here’s Perry expressing himself (minus his gun)……saying border, border, border. Like this strip of land is the problem. What about everybody flying in the sky above his border? WTF?

    1. bostonboomer Avatar
      bostonboomer

      He said we need a fleet of planes flying 24/7, plus technology to trace them. Isn’t that going to be kind of expensive?

      1. ANonOMouse Avatar
        ANonOMouse

        Well, maybe he’s going to make Mexico pay for it!

  14. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Next, the economy. Voodoo!!

  15. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Nobody wants to talk about VOTING rights………..come ‘on ya’ll

  16. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    I’ll let Hillary speak to Lady Lindsey’s bullshit.

    1. bostonboomer Avatar
      bostonboomer

      What an ass he is. I can’t stand to listen to his Mayberry accent.

  17. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Grow the economy, American are dying. For 50 years, they have proven that their policies work, and all the poor people are intruding on their life style. The problem is Hillary Clinton, the problem is Pres. Obama. Let’s fight some more wars, no body is dying there.

  18. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Bobby Jindal is asked about expanding Medicaid.

    Bla bla bla . . . Obama and Clinton are socialists . . . bla bla bla…..

    1. dakinikat Avatar

      It’s from the Onion!!!
      Bobby Jindal Vows To Return America To Time When He Was Rising Republican Star

      http://www.theonion.com/article/bobby-jindal-vows-return-america-time-when-he-was–51029

  19. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    How many employees did Jindal fire? 35,000 fucking employees fired.

  20. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Oh lord. Next they’re going to talk about Planned Parenthood and the Supreme Court.

  21. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Oh Lord, here they come Planned Parenthood, and Supreme Court. They need Ted Cruz to talk about the supreme court, don’t you think?

    1. RalphB Avatar
      RalphB

      Definitely. I’m not watching this horseshit but enjoying the live blog and twitter reactions. 🙂

      1. bostonboomer Avatar
        bostonboomer

        Thanks, Ralph. I need to get on twitter too.

      2. ANonOMouse Avatar
        ANonOMouse

        The gay twittersphere was telling Lady Lindsey to make a big splash by coming out during the debate

        1. bostonboomer Avatar
          bostonboomer

          That would have been a lot more interesting.

    2. Fannie Avatar
      Fannie

      Funny BB, you and I are on the same wavelength. I know for sure I’ll be sticking my tongue out in a minute or two.

  22. RalphB Avatar
    RalphB

    Why do you all suck so much? Why is Donald Trump kicking your ass so bad, you fucking punks?

    Should have been the first 2 questions.

    1. bostonboomer Avatar
      bostonboomer

      lol

      They did kind of ask that.

    2. Fannie Avatar
      Fannie

      Yep, they did early on. Everybody shined him on since you know he’s a actor, been on TV, and that is why he’s doing some ass kicking, everybody knows him.

  23. RalphB Avatar
    RalphB

    Rick Perry sounds like Miss Teen South Carolina.

    1. ANonOMouse Avatar
      ANonOMouse

      He certainly was demure acting, but I really liked the red velvet box he was standing on, it went well with his suit.

  24. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Oh shit, we aren’t sending money to Iran. Perry is all fucked up, and said he’d make Carly his SOS.

    1. bostonboomer Avatar
      bostonboomer

      Carly is so annoying. “I know our Arab allies personally.”

    2. roofingbird Avatar

      What kind of sexist attack is that?

  25. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Carly, let’s get on the get foot. American does not lead, Obama breaks every fucking rule ever made in USA. I’d go to Camp David, and have a nice happy happy hour.

  26. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Oh, hell “get on the good foot”.

  27. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Rick Santorum says SCOTUS is wrong about same-sex marriage, and that decision was just like Dred Scott. Then he goes off ranting on abortion.

  28. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Commercial break, thank goodness.

  29. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    What Santorum is NOT saying is that when there is constitutional question, it is the supreme court who decides the answer, not the presidency, and not the legislative body.

    1. bostonboomer Avatar
      bostonboomer

      Luckily, Santorum will never be involved in government again.

  30. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Defund, defund defund at conception.

  31. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Defund, defund, defund, and shut down, shut down, and shut down.

    1. RalphB Avatar
      RalphB

      Mark Zuckerberg donated $992 million to a charity than funds Planned Parenthood. Will conservatives boycott Facebook?

      1. Fannie Avatar
        Fannie

        I read that, but I though he donated 992 million to charity, and some of that included planned parenthood. But he did donate.

        1. RalphB Avatar
          RalphB

          One of the charitys priorities is Planned Parenthood.

          1. Fannie Avatar
            Fannie

            Yes it is Ralph.

  32. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Graham says that we need to stop women from killing babies. And the only way to do that is vote for him.

    1. bostonboomer Avatar
      bostonboomer

      We need to stop Republicans from killing women!!

      1. ANonOMouse Avatar
        ANonOMouse

        That would make a good outline for a Hillary commercial.

    2. ANonOMouse Avatar
      ANonOMouse

      Because Graham is such an expert on women.

      1. bostonboomer Avatar
        bostonboomer

        Right.

  33. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Everytime Graham speaks he changes the subject, and calls on troops to be put on the ground all over the world.

    1. ANonOMouse Avatar
      ANonOMouse

      I noticed that too Fannie. I think it’s likely his “men at war” fetish.

  34. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Undoing Obama, everything he has ever done.

  35. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Let me go back one more time, didn’t Graham say he would not allow harvesting of stem cell/tissue for women having abortions. What about everybody harvesting organs, and stem cells, is he going to stop them too?

  36. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Rick on a freedom kick. Ain’t it funny, he can’t talk sex and personal freedom in the same sentence.

    Oh, poor old boy, Graham, I was so poor.

  37. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    Hillary, likeable enough: She has no vision, she’s untrustworthy, she’s a socialist, she’s not the change we need, she can’t ever be trusted.

  38. Fannie Avatar
    Fannie

    These clowns all want to get on the warpath in the middle east. Make no doubt about it, if they win, we will have WAR like no other. Sen. Graham wants to reinvade every fucking country in the middle east, not just one, but the whole fucking middle east.

    All the clowns will repeal anything and everything Obama has done in the last 8 years, they all are real about doing this when they become President.

    They had NO fucking solutions, everything is about Hillary/Obama. They intend on cutting up the fucking pie before it’s even served up, because they are the republican bandits.

    1. bostonboomer Avatar
      bostonboomer

      Ugh! I had to take a break to make some coffee. I can’t stand to listen to these people.

      1. bostonboomer Avatar
        bostonboomer

        I’ll put up another live blog for the 9PM hatefest.

        1. Fannie Avatar
          Fannie

          I’m going to have to “let the label tell the truth”……………and hit the Colonel E. H. Taylor, Jr. for some straight bourbon on the next go around.

          1. ANonOMouse Avatar
            ANonOMouse

            Yeah, I too think I’m going to have to crack open a few Michelob’s. I can’t imagine listening to this next round of BS completely sober.

            1. JJ Lopez Minkoff Avatar

              Damn, I thought the debate started at 8….looks like I missed most of the show.

          2. bostonboomer Avatar
            bostonboomer

            Sadly, I have no choice. Maybe I’ll pop a couple of Benedryls.

          3. ANonOMouse Avatar
            ANonOMouse

            LOL!!!

          4. bostonboomer Avatar
            bostonboomer

            JJ,

            The main event starts at 9PM. I’m going to put up another live blog for that.

            1. JJ Lopez Minkoff Avatar

              Sorry BB thanks for clarifying it. I think my brain is in serious dumbass mode, with all the GOP debate talk going around.

  39. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer

    Lindsey Graham gets America to Google him

    Lindsey Graham’s brief, morose comments about the difficult times of his life appears to have spurred a huge spike in search interest for the South Carolina senator. He talked about the death of his parents at about 6:10 p.m. — and Google searches for him spiked immediately afterward.

    Graham said:

    When I was 21, my mom died. When I was 22, my dad died. We owned a liquor store, restaurant, bar and we lived in the back. Every penny we needed from — every penny we got from Social Security, because my sister was a minor, we needed. Today, I’m 60, I’m not married, I don’t have any kids. I would give up some Social Security to save a system that Americans are going to depend on now and in the future.

    And right after, searches for his name spiked.

  40. bostonboomer Avatar
    bostonboomer
    1. ANonOMouse Avatar
      ANonOMouse

      Frothy Mix is terribly mixed up. Does he know that the first person to attempt to use the Dred Scott Decision as an analogy to the pending Marriage Equality decision was Alabama Supreme Court Justice Roy Moore? The two decisions are not analogous and in fact are in direct contrast. And Frothy Mix brags about his knowledge of the Constitution? I suppose he thinks American’s are incapable of googling the Dred Scott decision to find out this his analogy is a LIE?

  41. dakinikat Avatar

    Why the Hell Are You Here? The Awkward Opening Questions of the GOP Consolation Debate

    http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slatest/2015/08/06/fox_news_debate_questions_moderators_bill_hemmer_martha_maccallum_begin.html

    Here they were, in order:

    1.) Hemmer to Rick Perry: “You recently said four years ago you weren’t ready for this job, why should someone vote for you now?”

    2.) MacCullum to Carly Fiorina: “This week you said that Margaret Thatcher was not content to manage a great nation in decline and ‘neither am I.’ Given your current standing in the polls, is the Iron Lady comparison a stretch?”

    3.) Hemmer to Rick Santorum: “You won the Iowa caucus four years ago and 10 other states, but you failed to beat Mitt Romney for the nomination. … Has your moment passed, senator?

    4.) MacCallum to Bobby Jindal: “Your approval numbers at home are in the mid-30s at this point. In a recent poll that showed you in a head-to-head with Hillary Clinton in Louisiana, she beat you by several points. So if the people of Louisiana are not satisfied, what makes you think the people of this nation would be?”

    5.) Hemmer to Lindsey Graham: “You worked with Democrats and President Obama when it came to climate change, something you know is extremely unpopular with conservative Republicans. How can they trust you based on that record?”

    6.) MacCallum to George Pataki: “Four years ago this month you called it quits in a race for the presidency but now you’re back. Mitt Romney declined to run this time because the party needed new blood. Does he have a point?”

    7.) Hemmer to Jim Gilmore: You were the last person on stage to declare your candidacy. You ran for the White House once and lost, you ran for the Senate one time and lost, you haven’t held office in 13 years. Similar question: Is it time for new blood?”

    That just about sums up the entire thing.