Monday Reads
Posted: September 8, 2014 Filed under: morning reads | Tags: DNA analysis, identity of Jack the Ripper 66 CommentsGood Morning!
So, I’m really tired of the political news right now. The global news is depressing. That goes without saying. So, here’s a little distraction for your morning coffee.
DNA tests appears may have identified Jack the Ripper.
It is the greatest murder mystery of all time, a puzzle that has perplexed criminologists for more than a century and spawned books, films and myriad theories ranging from the plausible to the utterly bizarre.
But now, thanks to modern forensic science, The Mail on Sunday can exclusively reveal the true identity of Jack the Ripper, the serial killer responsible for at least five grisly murders in Whitechapel in East London during the autumn of 1888.
DNA evidence has now shown beyond reasonable doubt which one of six key suspects commonly cited in connection with the Ripper’s reign of terror was the actual killer – and we reveal his identity.
A shawl found by the body of Catherine Eddowes, one of the Ripper’s victims, has been analysed and found to contain DNA from her blood as well as DNA from the killer.
The landmark discovery was made after businessman Russell Edwards, 48, bought the shawl at auction and enlisted the help of Dr Jari Louhelainen, a world-renowned expert in analysing genetic evidence from historical crime scenes.
Using cutting-edge techniques, Dr Louhelainen was able to extract 126-year-old DNA from the material and compare it to DNA from descendants of Eddowes and the suspect, with both proving a perfect match.
The revelation puts an end to the fevered speculation over the Ripper’s identity which has lasted since his murderous rampage in the most impoverished and dangerous streets of London.
A DNA sample has proven Polish immigrant Aaron Kosminski was Jack the Ripper. The owner of the shawl shares his story and the forensic and criminal research from the Ripper scenes.
Before buying it, I spoke to Alan McCormack, the officer in charge of the Crime Museum, also known as the Black Museum. He told me the police had always believed they knew the identity of the Ripper. Chief Inspector Donald Swanson, the officer in charge of the investigation, had named him in his notes: Aaron Kosminski, a Polish Jew who had fled to London with his family, escaping the Russian pogroms, in the early 1880s.
Kosminski has always been one of the three most credible suspects. He is often described as having been a hairdresser in Whitechapel, the occupation written on his admission papers to the workhouse in 1890. What is certain is he was seriously mentally ill, probably a paranoid schizophrenic who suffered auditory hallucinations and described as a misogynist prone to ‘self-abuse’ – a euphemism for masturbation.
McCormack said police did not have enough evidence to convict Kosminski, despite identification by a witness, but kept him under 24-hour surveillance until he was committed to mental asylums for the rest of his life. I became convinced Kosminski was our man, and I was excited at the prospect of proving it. I felt sure that modern science would be able to produce real evidence from the stains on the shawl. After a few false starts, I found a scientist I hoped could help.
A Pennsylvania mom is headed for prison for giving her daughter miscarriage-inducing pills. This is pretty much what you get when you make abortion difficult and expensive.
A Pennsylvania woman has been sentenced to up to 18 months in prison for obtaining so-called abortion pills online and providing them to her teenage daughter to end her pregnancy.
Jennifer Ann Whalen, 39, of Washingtonville, a single mother who works as a nursing home aide, pleaded guilty in August to obtaining the miscarriage-inducing pills from an online site in Europe for her daughter, 16, who did not want to have the child.
Whalen was sentenced on Friday by Montour County Court of Common Pleas Judge Gary Norton to serve 12 months to 18 months in prison for violating a state law that requires abortions to be performed by physicians.
She was also fined $1,000 and ordered to perform 40 hours of community service after her release. The felony offense called for up to seven years in prison and a $15,000 fine.
Matthew Bingham Banks, Whalen’s lawyer, previously told Reuters criminal prosecutions of this kind were not common.
Whalen told authorities there was no local clinic available to perform an abortion and her daughter did not have health insurance to cover a hospital abortion, the Press Enterprise newspaper of Bloomsburg reported.
Her daughter experienced severe cramping and bleeding after taking the pills and Whalen took her to a hospital near her home for treatment, the newspaper said.
The closest abortion clinic to Whalen’s home is about 74 miles away in Harrisburg.
The Pennsylvania case follows the prosecution of a Florida man who pleaded guilty to tricking his girlfriend into taking an abortion pill. He was sentenced in January to 13 years in prison and $28,500 restitution. In June, Florida toughened state law to allow for prosecutions in the death of non-viable fetuses.
How can a chemically induced miscarriage be considered “performing” an abortion which sounds somewhat surgical to me? Suppose I will have to ask Doctor Daughter this question next time I talk to her.
Textbooks segregate twenty-five decades of enslavement into one chapter, painting a static picture. Millions of people each year visit plantation homes where guides blather on about furniture and silverware. As sites, such homes hide the real purpose of these places, which was to make African Americans toil under the hot sun for the profit of the rest of the world. All this is the “symbolic annihilation” of enslaved people, as two scholars of those weird places put it.2 Meanwhile, at other points we tell slavery’s story by heaping praise on those who escaped it through flight or death in rebellion, leaving the listener to wonder if those who didn’t flee or die somehow “accepted” slavery. And everyone who teaches about slavery knows a little dirty secret that reveals historians’ collective failure: many African-American students struggle with a sense of shame that most of their ancestors could not escape the suffering they experienced.
The truth can set us free, if we can find the right questions. But back in the little house in Danville, Anderson was reading from a list of leading ones, designed by white officials—some well- meaning, some not so well-meaning. He surely felt how the gravity of the questions pulled him toward the planet of plantation nostalgia. “Did slaves mind being called ‘nigger’?” “What did slaves call master or mistress?” “Have you been happier in slavery or free?” “Was the mansion house pretty?” Escaping from chains is very difficult, however, so Anderson dutifully asked the prescribed questions and poised his pencil to take notes.
Ivy listened politely. He sat still. Then he began to speak: “My mother’s master was named William Tunstall. He was a mean man. There was only one good thing he did, and I don’t reckon he intended to do that. He sold our family to my father’s master George H. Gilman.”
Perhaps the wind blowing through the window changed as a cloud moved across the spring sun: “Old Tunstall caught the ‘cotton fever.’ There was a fever going round, leastways it was like a fever. Everyone was dying to get down south and grow cotton to sell. So old Tunstall separated families right and left. He took two of my aunts and left their husbands up here, and he separated altogether seven husbands and wives. One woman had twelve children. Yessir. Took ‘em all down south with him to Georgia and Alabama.”
Pervasive separations. Tears carving lines on faces. Lorenzo remembered his relief at dodging the worst, but he also remembered knowing that it was just a lucky break. Next time it could’ve been his mother. No white person was reliable, because money drove their decisions. No, this wasn’t the story the books told.
So Anderson moved to the next question. Did Ivy know if any slaves had been sold here? Now, perhaps, the room grew darker.
For more than a century, white people in the United States had been singling out slave traders as an exception: unscrupulous lower-class outsiders who pried apart paternalist bonds. Scapegoaters had a noble precedent. In his first draft of the Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson tried to blame King George III for using the Atlantic slave trade to impose slavery on the colonies. In historians’ tellings, the 1808 abolition of the Atlantic trade brought stability to slavery, ringing in the “Old South,” as it has been called since before the Civil War. Of course, one might wonder how something that was brand new, created after a revolution, and growing more rapidly than any other commodity-producing economy in history before then could be considered “old.” But never mind. Historians depicted slave trading after 1808 as irrelevant to what slavery was in the “Old South,” and to how America as a whole was shaped. America’s modernization was about entrepreneurs, creativity, invention, markets, movement, and change. Slavery was not about any of these things—not about slave trading, or moving people away from everyone they knew in order to make them make cotton. Therefore, modern America and slavery had nothing to do with each
When Cornell University professor Ed Baptist read The Economist review of his book on slavery, he knew that it would be a big deal. The review dismissed his work as “advocacy” because “all the blacks in his book are victims, almost all the whites villains.”
That characterization of his work, which attracted the most backlash from journalists and academics, was not entirely a surprise to Baptist, he told TPM on Friday. It is something he has heard in history circles before the reaction to his new book, “The Half Has Never Been Told.”
“I thought that was silly,” he said. “But I’ve been talking about this kind of stuff for a while in academic circles and public history circles, and it’s not uncommon for people to protest that I’m not being sensitive enough to the inner lives of enslavers.”
“On one level, I want to respond, ‘No, actually, I think I’m being very sensitive to it and I’m just unfurling these other sides to the story that are often left under the sheets as it were,'” he continued. “The point that other people have made that I think is so effective is that for me to write a book about the exploitation of enslaved people, by definition, is going to show enslaved people as the objects of all kinds of victimizing processes and, on the other hand, enslavers as the agents of those processes.”
The Economist did apologize and withdraw the review, though Baptist said he believed the magazine had only apologized for the last line on “victims” and “villains.” Another bit of the review, which questioned the reliability of ex-slaves in relating experiences under slavery, struck him as “blatantly racist.”
“One thing that really did aggravate me about the review was this suggestion and this sort of implicit argument that ex-slaves had some sort of vested interest and are unreliable reporters on what actually happened,” he said. “That is such an old struggle when you’re talking about the history of slavery, the constant undermining of testimony from survivors.”
“That was not apologized for,” he said, “and that was I thought blatantly racist, blatantly something that you would have heard in the 1850s or something like that.”
It’s amazing to me that we still have such a profound level of racism in the world and in this country. Of course, the sexism overwhelms me too. I’m trying to be much more aware of the idea of swimming in privilege.
So, hopefully this little thread will get you to share what you’re reading and blogging today.





Hi Dakinikat,
I’m glad you brought up the Economist review of Baptist’s book on slavery as the foundation of American capitalism.
I read the review after I saw Tommy Christopher’s post on it a couple of days ago. As I pointed out at The Daily Banter, the Economist review also failed to mention the routine rapes of slave women by slave holders. As usual, women’s experiences are ignored. I searched the book on amazon and the author did deal with the treatment of women under slavery a few times. I plan to check out the book in the future.
Thanks for a fascinating post. The Jack the Ripper story is amazing. I’ll be interested to see what other Ripperologists have to say about this. I know many consider Kosminski to be the most credible suspect. The murders were clearly done by a highly disorganized killer, most likely mentally ill.
The PA story about the mother helping her daughter have a miscarriage and going to jail for it is heartbreaking. We have gone nearly full-circle, back to the way things were when I was young. It’s horrible.
Just the story of a police officer bringing home a bloody shawl to his wife was wild to me. That she and others saved it and stashed it for many years is wild too. The science on the DNA extraction is wild too. I wonder how much might learn from other cases like the Lizzie Borden story if some evidence still exists?
Yes, keeping the bloody shawl was weird. It’s also amazing that no one thought to examine the DNA until now.
The doctor had to invent a procedure to get at the DNA. I guess up until about 5 years ago, it would’ve been impossible.
There is so much to be fascinated with and yet so much to be outraged about in this post. Where to begin? The yellow orbs are fascinating. Maybe an early form of those bins of balls that kids can jump into?
That Jennifer Whalen is actually going to jail for getting her daughter an abortion pill is absolutely shocking. I guess we all knew it could come to this but how could any judge sentence a poor woman to jail time, 18 months!!!!, and so much community service that certainly she has already lost her job and whatever reputation and status in her community she had. How is that not cruel and unusual punishment considering the “crime” she committed? How does that make any sense? And yet the feds were going to let the McDonnells off with no jail time for all of the theft they committed. I guess Ms. Whalen should consider herself lucky she wasn’t burned at the stake for being a witch.
I read the Economist book review and the retraction. How disgusting is it that some insist that we paint enslavers in a more positive light?
The right is bubbling over with racism and misogyny and contempt for the poor to such an extent that they just can’t contain it anymore.
I was wondering how much connection it had to our slavery experience. It seems some men still think they can own women and others. It’s just not slavery, more like indentured servitude to them.
That’s what I thought, too. The old attitude that women (and children) who’ve been raped or otherwise abused are exaggerating or making it up.
….sounds just like the complaints that prosecuting a HS football start for rape is going to ruin his life. Whereas it’s OK to not be concerned about the lives of the girls/women who’ve been raped.
Exactly.
I have to think that no matter how bad we think things were for the slaves, no matter how bad African Americans believed it was for the slaves it was much, much, much worse. No one should ever sugar coat what those unfortunate people went through or be ashamed of them for not being able to fight back. I just don’t think there is any possible way to overstate the horror and atrocities inflicted upon them and there should never, ever be any sympathy towards people who owned slaves no matter how benevolent they allegedly were.
Exactly. Just the daily horror of knowing that at any moment, for any reason, you could be beaten or killed and then add in the brutality of day to day living with no hope whatsoever of escape. That anyone could see anything positive about slavery is disgusting.
I still can’t fathom the horror of even surviving one of those ships and the markets let alone being separated from your family and doing miserable physical work in the southern heat.
Another article by Edward Baptist at Politico:
What the Economist Doesn’t Get About Slavery–and My Book
A piece by Blattman that discusses the efficiency for forced labor based on research:
What The Economist should have read before suggesting that US slavery wasn’t always so bad
The review was essentially another example of “mansplaining”.
Tommy Christopher called it “whitesplaining.”
lol
That’s so adorable …
Finally! May they have many happy years ahead!
Best thing I’ve seen in awhile. Just great!
Video of the knockout punch that Ray Rice only got a two-game suspension for at TMZ. Unbelievable. And she married him! As TMZ points out, Michael Vick got a prison sentence for abusing dogs. Rice deserves the same. I’d like to see him put in stocks in the public square.
http://www.tmz.com/2014/09/08/ray-rice-elevator-knockout-fiancee-takes-crushing-punch-video/
Fox hosts giggle that NFL player’s abused girlfriend should learn to ‘take the stairs’
http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/09/08/fox-hosts-giggle-that-nfl-players-abused-girlfriend-should-learn-to-take-the-stairs/#.VA3m2J6NP0E.twitter
Incredible. What an ass!!!
There was nothing cute or funny about this, and to suggest the solution would have been “take the stairs”, just pisses me off even more.
Me too. To be frank, it makes me want to kick those Fox idiots down a very long, long flight of concrete stairs.
http://www.sbnation.com/lookit/2014/9/8/6121697/terrance-knighton-tweets-nfl-ray-rice-video
Here’s Broncos player that says Rice should be thrown out of the NFL and jailed.
Ray Rice’s contract terminated by Ravens
ww.sbnation.com/nfl/2014/9/8/6121917/ray-rice-cut-ravens-suspension
I just saw they released him! Fantastic. Now let’s see if any other team has the nerve to pick him up. I doubt it.
I’m worried about his wife. She needs to be in a shelter some where. This is not going to make him a happy camper.
Let’s hope she has supportive relatives and they can get her away from him.
Yup, Has Peter King Read His Own Reporting On The Ray Rice Fiasco?
My internet is out then on for a few minutes then out again.
There is a guy who is running for Georgia superintendent of schools that is an oathkeeper and tea party nut…he calls for “Georgia-grown” education standards. GA candidate: Black female opponent can’t win by ‘dusting off copies of The Color Purple’
I was just reading about that. Peter King used to be a good reporter. Now, not so much.
Top trend on Twitter. I saw the video, it’s shocking. But then I guess we all knew he didn’t knock her out cold by yelling at her. All of us except the NFL. I’m glad the Ravens cut him. A baby step in the right direction for domestic violence.
The NFL has now suspended him indefinitely! This is huge!
http://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/nfl/ravens/2014/09/08/baltimore-ravens-cut-ray-rice/15291729/
It is huge. As soon as the Ravens cut him people were speculating as to which team would pick him up. Now none of them will. May this be to domestic violence in the world of professional sports as the Donald Sterling comments were to revealing the racist underside of professional team ownership. I wonder how many Donald Sterling apologists (and shockingly there are many) who insist that he is the victim since he had an expectation of privacy will also see Ray Rice as a victim since he was in a closed elevator. Clearly the chuckle heads on Fox News think so with their “… remember, there cameras in elevators…” remark.
The Ravens probably heard about the suspension before they released him.
WTF?
Shaneen Allen is being completely screwed here and it started when the police arrested her for what should have been a warning offense to an out-of-state resident about local gun laws. Then the ludicrous misuse of prosecutorial discretion by a district attorney.
Just a guess but Ms Allen is likely African-American while the cop and prosecutor are not.
He needs to go down like the Titantic did. He cold cocked her with a punch to the face. Then it looks like five men arrived to look at his handi work, and did nothing, turned their heads the other way. They are as much a savage as he, they were in a position to call police and have her medically checked out, and speak up. I guess they were afraid they’d be struck in their teeth, or they have seen it so many times, that they could care less because she was out of her head, not Ray Rice. She staggers to get up, and the NFL didn’t want to stop him either. Until this video. It’s horrible.
He also spit in her face.
What a sadist!
ISIS’s Enemy List: 10 Reasons the Islamic State Is Doomed, by Kurt Eichenwald
http://www.newsweek.com/isiss-enemy-list-10-reasons-islamic-state-doomed-268953
Provided we have the moral courage to only do what is absolutely necessary to prevent some kind of genocide, while letting nature run it’s course, I think Eichenwald is largely correct.
An energy boom lifts the heartland (NYT).
An energy boom is seemingly lifting the heartland but is long term killing it at the same time.
I know. Damned if they do; damned if they don’t.
Yes. It is. The should learn from us. Texas and Louisiana both have dying water supplies and ecosystems and people and animals.
Wash. state megachurch closes branches after founder is caught calling women ‘penis homes’
http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/09/08/wash-state-megachurch-closes-branches-after-founder-is-caught-calling-women-penis-homes/
I remember this church well, we discussed it some time ago. I’ll try to find more, because I remember several church members exposed the sexism, and they dishonored their membership in the church.
That church. I was happy to read this morning in our local paper that it is folding fast.
http://seattletimes.com/text/2024485113.html
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2746472/Inside-tiny-town-built-sex-offenders-Photographer-captures-spiritual-safe-haven-Florida-200-convicted-sex-criminals-relatives-live-side.html
Geologists say they’ve found evidence that oxygen-producing life existed on Earth some 3.02 billion years ago–60 million years earlier than previously thought.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/09/08/life-on-earth-existed-way-earlier_n_5781840.html?ir=Science
So cool!
I’ve been listening to the Boston sports talk station this afternoon. They’ve been playing the press conference Ray Rice held in May (courtesy of the Ravens) after he and his wife had “counseling.” Rice apologizes to everyone under the sun–except his wife who is sitting silently behind him. Rice acted like they were both equally at fault. Then at the end, his wife says she’s sorry for her part in the incident! After that, the Ravens tweeted that–that she felt bad for what she did to cause the assault.
Today, the Ravens deleted that tweet, and
removed the press conference video and any mentions or photos of Rice from their website.They just can’t wait for this to blow over. The NFL too, I’m sure. Unfortunately for them, the Ravens are playing on national TV on Thursday night. I wonder what the commentators will be talking about?Watch the press conference here (fixed):
http://www.baltimoreravens.com/videos/videos/Ray-Rices-Full-Press-Conference/405fea46-d4d4-44c7-b381-33497bf6d12f
Here’s an article about the press conference at SB Nation.
Ray Rice is an asshole and the Ravens couldn’t care less
http://www.sbnation.com/nfl/2014/5/23/5745888/ray-rice-wife-apology-assault-domestic-violence-ravens
Same organization that let Ray Lewis play for years after his conviction for his role in a double murder.
Yes, and today Lewis claimed his situation and Rice’s were “night and day.”
http://www.baltimoresun.com/sports/ravens/ravens-insider/bal-ray-lewis-weighs-in-on-ray-rice-situation-calls-it-night-and-day-to-his-past-legal-problems-20140908,0,3001675.story
Hey, American workers: Your bosses would rather outsource you.
http://seattletimes.com/text/2024488839.html
While another article a bit later has this:
Mysterious. Really? Dak could tell them a thing or two. And I suspect it’s more the media that’s mystified.
This sounds promising:
http://seattletimes.com/text/2024489225.html
Great. These guys need a dose of bad karma.
I wish nothing but pain and suffering for those fat cats.
Scott Brown Threatens Lawsuit Over Being Called a ‘Washington Lobbyist’
He and Sarah Palin should have a dumb-off contest.