Misreading Elections

Politicians these days represent narrow interests and are deliberately misrepresenting recent election results as support for policies not presented to the general electorate during their campaigns. Some of this agenda may have been possibly inkled to their extremists supporters through code words but from the looks of polls, most of it appears to have come as a complete surprise to their electorate.  This is probably because people generally don’t pay attention to primaries and the types of candidates supported by the most vocal and most extreme partisans.

No where is this disconnect more clear than in Wisconsin where poll-after-poll shows buyer’s remorse for their right wing extremist governor, Scott Walker. The latest Rasmussen Poll shows support for Budget Cuts but not state usurpation of collective bargaining rights for state workers.

Most Wisconsin voters oppose efforts to weaken collective bargaining rights for union workers but a plurality are supportive of significant pay cuts for state workers. Governor Scott Walker is struggling in the court of public opinion, but how badly he is struggling depends upon how the issue is presented.  There is also an interesting gap between the views of private and public sector union families.

A new Rasmussen Reports telephone survey of Wisconsin voters shows that just 39% favor weakening collective bargaining rights and 52% are opposed. At the same time, 44% support a 10% pay cut for all state workers. Thirty-eight percent (38%) are opposed. That’s partly because 27% of Wisconsin voters believe state workers are paid too much and 16% believe they are paid too little. Forty-nine percent (49%) believe the pay of state workers is about right. (To see survey question wording, click here.)

Strong support for collective bargaining rights showed up in a WSJ/NBC Poll yesterday where only 33% supported limited collective bargaining rights.  This result supported an early poll done by US Today who found the same 33% level of support. Yet, we continue to see bills advance that would erode these rights.  Ohio state senators barely advanced a bill with drastic limitations.  I’m getting qualified in a few months as a professor in one of the few high demand, high paying areas. That would be finance. I’m one of very few white, American women to do so also.  This implies I have two additional job skills that are very difficult to find these days in people with technical doctorates.  I speak and write in coherent American English.  Many of my peers struggle to do their lectures and research in cogent English.  You can only imagine what this does to students.  I don’t have to imagine.  I hear the complaints all the time.  This is a problem for candidates coming from top tier schools.  Ask me if I’m interested in any place in Wisconsin or Ohio at the moment.  The answer is a big fat no. I’m looking outside Louisiana for similar reasons.  I’m not going to be drastically underpaid in cash without some compensating benefits.  I can’t imagine that similarly qualified folks in engineering, accounting, medical fields, and computer sciences aren’t having the same thoughts. I pity the poor administration that’s going to try to find qualified people in those areas under these circumstances.

Why do politicians find people like me so terrible and unprofessional that they seek to deny us a place in determining our working conditions and remuneration?

Ohio state senators narrowly approved a bill that would prohibit public-employee unions representing 400,000 state and local workers from bargaining over health benefits and pensions, while also eliminating the right to strike. I’ve never particularly felt the need to strike except in the private sector where I basically just have voted with my feet after finding another job.  The private sector is filled with capricious and overtly-political bad managers.  It’s why most corporations can’t compete unless they scramble to find extreme cost cutting measures. They don’t want to be bothered with the higher callings of research and development, customer service, or any other type of innovation that would actually benefit employees and customers.  This now appears to be the model that many of these folks want transferred to the public sector where you still had a chance of being paid and promoted on how well you do your job instead of whose ass you’re willing to frequently kiss. The problem now is that there is so much market in the hands of so few businesses and some jobs are only available through the public sector.  The power to abuse is very much in their favor.  This brings me back to the 2/3rds of the electorate that appreciate checks and balances.  Union power checks the power of huge oligopoly and monopoly employers.

This brings me to a story of excess and the  Northern Mariana Islands and Jack Abramoff.  This also includes notorious B I G  Felon, The Hammer, Republican Tom Delay (H/T to Bostonboomer for reminding me about this.).  It’s a story of sex trade, Republicans, a deregulation haven, and the type of things that Republicans would like to see hoisted on the US and American workers.  I have to admit to having to do some reading up on this since most of the story broke in 2006 and I was busy recovering from a little thing called Katrina at the time.  You may recall we were a ‘petri dish’ of privatization and no bid contracts at the time and still are the guinea pigs of US privatization scams.  What they did to us pales in comparison to the treatment of people in the US Territories of the Marianas Islands.

The Marianas Islands situation serves as a cautionary tale that would be worth remembering today because the same people who took jaunts to this paradise of no regulation and slavery are the same people stripping US citizens of rights our grandparents fought for during the gilded age.  Here’s NPR describing work compounds that delighted and tingled the legs of visiting Republican politicians.  JOHN YDSTIE is the NPR host.  He introduced his guest as “Wendy Doromol was a schoolteacher there in the 1980s and ’90s, but became a human rights activist fighting sweatshops after guest workers on the islands came to her with tales of abuse“.  Now remember, this is the work environment that Republican politicians like Scott Walker and John Kasich admire.

Ms. DOROMOL: The barbed wire around the factories face inward so that the mostly women couldn’t get out. They had quotas that were impossible for these people to reach and if they didn’t reach them, they’d have to stay until they finished the quota and they wouldn’t be paid for that work. They were hot, the barracks were horrible. A lot of the females were told you work during the day in the garment factory and then at night you can go and work in a club and they’d force them into prostitution at night.

YDSTIE: And they also experienced things like coerced abortion?

Ms. DOROMOL: Yes, if some female got pregnant, they either had to go back to China to give birth or have a forced abortion.

YDSTIE: Guest workers were lured to the Marianas by recruiters in countries like China, the Philippines and Bangladesh, who told them they were going to the United States. The recruiters charged workers around $5,000 for the trip. Nashir Jahidi(ph) is one of the workers Wendy Doromol befriended. He came to Saipan, one of the Northern Mariana Islands from Bangladesh by way of the Philippines. He says when he got on the plane, he thought he was going to America.

Mr. NASHIR JAHIDI (Ex-Worker): And not only me, there was some people that recruiter exactly told him that he can be going to Los Angeles by train from Saipan. So when I hear that the plane, you know, the host or somebody’s saying they were about to land in Saipan and I when I looked out the window and I saw it’s like blue water everywhere and small island and I was like, how?

YDSTIE: So you thought that you were going to be going to California or somewhere on the U.S. mainland?

Mr. JAHIDI: Not only me, most of the worker. They were surprised when they see the United States flag and the local island flag and we used the U.S. dollar, we used the U.S. stamp and everything, then people understand that this is only a small island. There is no way that you have the opportunity like what’s in the United States.

YDSTIE: Garment manufacturers were attracted to the Marianas, which had become a U.S. commonwealth in 1976, because clothes made there could be labeled made in the U.S.A. and didn’t face import quotas or duties. But despite flying the U.S. flag, the islands were exempt from many U.S. labor and immigration standards. As the abuses that Wendy Doromol helped uncover came to light, garment manufacturers there were sanctioned by the U.S. Labor Department. Then in the mid-1990s when it looked like Congress might force the Marianas to adopt U.S. Labor and Immigration laws, the island’s government took action. It hired lobbyist Jack Abramoff to protect its special status. Abramoff was paid millions for his work.

You may remember that Tom Delay got a lot of freebie trips to this Republican paradise via Jack Abramoff.  Please notice the comments that I highlighted in bold.  They should put into perspective the moves made by these extremist Republican governors, congressional critters and legislatures.

And, DeLay himself was recipient of several “free” trips paid for by the notorious lobbyist. One such trip was to the US territory of the Northern Mariana Islands.  DeLay and his family enjoyed some golf and some diving, while immigrant workers, predominately from Asia, slaved away in squalid conditions on the island to make clothes bearing the “Made in USA” label for companies like Gap and Liz Claiborne for about half of US minimum wage.  Workers there enjoy living behind barbed wire in shacks without running water, 12 hour work days 7 days a week and forced abortions.

After the trip, the Hammer declared the working conditions in the Marianas “A shining light for what is happening to the Republican Party,” and “everything that is good about what we are trying to do in America and leading the world in the free-market system,” “a perfect petri dish of capitalism.  It’s like my Galapagos Island.” I don’t think he was lying.  I believe he thought it was grand.   So grand in fact, that in 2000, as Republican House Whip, born again Christian DeLay blocked consideration of a bill written by UBER conservative Frank Murkowski of Alaska that would have offered the same protection and rights enjoyed by workers on the US mainland to workers in the Marianas.  The bill passed the Senate unanimously, but DeLay put the hammer to it before the House could even consider it.

Maybe it was the huge and unavoidable red light district in Saipan that had DeLay so distracted on his trip that he did not notice the atrocities being committed in the name of the free market.  Many of the immigrants are forced to turn to the sex trade to pay off the contracts they believed were getting them good jobs in “America”, so that they can finally go home.  An estimated 90% of Marianas’ prostitutes are former garment workers. Even if the prostitutes so caught his eye, surely he couldn’t miss the Department of Interior’s documentation of “forced abortions”.

The 30,000 or so immigrant workers were working to the tune of about $2 billion in retail sales at one time.  It is, therefore,  no surprise that the local Mariana government and the influential garment industry were opposed to any proposed changes to their “perfect petri dish of capitalism.”  They hired Abramoff for about $11 million, who, you know, sent good religious right Christians like Delay on cushy trips and garnered their support.  Who says you can’t buy love?  Or loyalty – to this day, DeLay stands by the “things he has said in the past and he stands by the votes he’s made (or blocked) that pertain to the islands,” said his spokesman to Ms. Magazine.

Here’s some more information on what American’s business warriors did to the people on the Marianas Islands from PBS and Bill Moyers.  I think that it’s absolutely ironic that his article starts with this question: Should U.S. territories be subject to the same laws as the United States itself. If so, why? If not, why not? The question now should be why are they trying to remove our current laws and make us more like the Marianas islands?  I’ll refer again to the bolded Tom Delay quote above. He and other Republicans consider it the perfect Republican business model right down to the forced abortions.

Aside from Puerto Rico, the Northern Mariana Islands are the only other insular commonwealth of the United States. The arrangement, which began in 1978, grants all indigenous inhabitants of the islands American citizenship and allows them to elect a local island government but excludes the right to vote in U.S. presidential elections. The government of the Northern Marianas benefits from substantial U.S. federal funds-in the form of subsidies and development assistance-administered by the Department of the Interior. The United States benefits by having a strategic military site in the Pacific.

Under the terms of their commonwealth agreement, the Northern Marianas also maintained the right to label “Made in the U.S.A.” all products manufactured on the islands — despite the fact that they had been given exemption from some federal labor laws, customs laws, immigration laws, quotas and tariffs laws.  By the late 1980s, this state of affairs had become a boon both for the island’s garment industry and for a slew of American apparel giants who could count on abundant cheap labor without sacrificing the sacred “U.S.A.” label.

During those years, the Northern Mariana’s garment and textile businesses exploded, with companies importing tens of thousands of foreign workers from China, the Philippines, Thailand, Cambodia, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh to stitch in their factories for roughly half the American minimum wage. These immigrants often paid thousands of dollars to loan sharks to bring them to Saipan with the promise of work and spent months, if not years, paying off their debts, if they found work at all. Workers were often housed in barracks behind barbed-wire fences, often in unsafe, overcrowded and unhygienic conditions, and were charged exorbitant amounts for their room and board.

In the early 1990s, the U.S. Department of Labor began looking into allegations of garment industry worker abuses, focusing on factories owned by one of Saipan’s biggest employers, Willie Tan. In 1992, the department filed suit against Tan and ordered him to pay $9 million in back wages and damages to workers at five of his plants-at the time, the largest fine ever imposed by the Department of Labor. The suit alleged that employees were forced to work more than 80 hours a week, below the islands’ already low minimum wage and with no overtime. Further, workers were kept locked inside their barracks and were not allowed to leave during their off-work hours

So, deliberating misleading voters into thinking that it’s all about saving a few dollars is just one of the issues that we need to worry about when it comes to these governors and these legislators.Not only do we have them misreading the public’s intent on this, there’s another WSJ poll worth mentioning here: Poll Shows Budget-Cuts Dilemma.

Many Deem Big Cuts to Entitlements ‘Unacceptable,’ but Retirement and Means Testing Draw Support

The electorate is looking for a sensible, rationale middle ground which they believed they were going to get if they set up more checks and balances between the two party interests.  Poll-after-poll shows that they are not interested in absolute austerity, tax cuts for billionaires, and complete removal of the safety net and working conditions that use the Marianas Islands as a model. Voters’  lack of confidence in the crew that brought us so-called Health Care Reform was not a mandate for wholesale return to the gilded age.

26 Comments on “Misreading Elections”

  1. bostonboomer says:

    This is an excellent, excellent post, Dak. Thank you for pulling all this together. It makes me sick that our Congress went along with this. Of course now we know they’re ready to do the same thing to the rest of us on the mainland.

    • bostonboomer says:

      Please note the Tan family were (are?) huge political donors to both parties.

      • dakinikat says:

        You know, I really want to look into what has happened with these people. Some of them should be jailed for a very long time.

      • dakinikat says:

        Jack Abramoff was released on December 3, 2010. Delay just got 3 years for money laundering in January. Too bad that not reporting enslavement doesn’t carry a life sentence.

      • bostonboomer says:

        Some have gone to jail, but very few. There was a guy in Ohio and one in CA who got prison time. I’d have to look up the name.

      • dakinikat says:

        Chinese crime boss and sweatshop owner Tan Siu Lin was able to launder money through Abramoff to a number of GOP legislators and committees at the same time the US Interior Department was issuing reports to Young about horrendous working conditions and the growth of organized crime at Tan family-owned businesses in the Marianas.


  2. dakinikat says:

    Oh, and you may be interested in reading this:

    Chinese national, Chun Yu Wang, in her 2009 book, Chicken Feathers and Garlic Skin: Diary of a Chinese Garment Factory Girl on Saipan (as told to Walt F.J. Goodridge), provides the only known first-hand account of factory work conditions and life in the barracks, and provides revealing insights from a Chinese perspective into the experience typical of many of the garment factory workers on Saipan.

    • dakinikat says:

      or this:

      In John Bowe’s 2007 book Nobodies: Modern American Slave Labor and the Dark Side of the New Global Economy, he provides a focus on Saipan, exploring how its culture, isolation and American ties have made it a favorable environment for exploitative garment manufacturers and corrupt politicos. Bowe goes into detail about the island’s factories, and also its karaoke bars and strip joints, some of which have had connections with politicos. The author depicts Saipan as a vulnerable, truly suffering community, where poverty rates have climbed as high as 35 percent, and proposes that the guest worker setup, by allowing many native islanders to avoid work, has actually crippled the competitiveness and job readiness of the native population.

    • janicen says:

      Thanks for the tip. I just read what little of it is available on Amazon, and I can’t wait to read the whole thing.

    • dakinikat says:

      As far as I can tell, Tan Holdings is still functional and still in the US territories like Guam and Saipan:


      • bostonboomer says:

        That’s what I figured. I’m not sure the conditions have even changed. I don’t know if the legislation ever passed or if it was weakened. My guess is this is still going on.

    • bostonboomer says:

      Reps John Doolittle and Dana Rohrabacher of CA were brought down by the Abramoff scandal. I don’t know if they did any jail time.

  3. janicen says:

    I agree with BB, this is an excellent post. Reading about the conditions being forced upon workers in the Marianas Islands almost brought me to tears. This is horrifying.

    The Tea Party has managed to pull off one of the greatest political bate-and-switch schemes ever perpetrated. I distinctly remember their leaders being interviewed about the right wing leanings of some of their members and they responded adamantly that they welcomed people from many different parts of the political spectrum who were uniting against the favored treatment of big banks and Wall Street, and the suffering of people losing their homes and jobs. They really sounded like they were populists. Now that they’ve won a few elections, we are seeing what they are really about.

    • dakinikat says:

      I’m hoping this puts an end to all the romantic notions about what the Tea Party represents put forth by some very confused people who are wishful thinking.

      • paper doll says:

        Great post!

        The tea party was an astroturf from the get go. I use to wander what happened to the swift boaters… well they mutated into the tea party …Right wing shock troops that took advantage of people’s discontent with Barry when Left went flat-line when it came to their dreamboat and holding his feet to the fire…(lol! No, that’s only for the Clintons!) There was always a difference between the backers and many gathered in…but something that gets up and running , and even more, press time, is a upper crust astroturf…has to be if it’s in the media over night and 24/7( when needed ) or at all.

        It should mutated into something else down the road…sons of promise keepers? Anything is possible

      • Tea Party represents crazymaking–tea party leader thinks Charlie Sheen makes more sense than John Boehner…


  4. OT:

    Mubarak ally quits as Egyptian PM

    By Agence France-Presse
    Thursday, March 3rd, 2011 — 10:00 am

    CAIRO (AFP) – Egyptian Prime Minister Ahmed Shafiq resigned unexpectedly Thursday, sparking celebrations from protesters who demand a purge of the remnants of ousted president Hosni Mubarak’s regime.

  5. Excellent article – and I’m not just saying that because you used my work in it. It is a great comprehensive view of the bait and switch tactics the conservatives have been using for 30 years. Well researched and to the point – I’d like to repost it over at TCL.

  6. Joanelle says:

    Great post Dak – I remember reading about this back right before the primaries and then I got distracted by the Great nomination robbery.

    Thanks for this.

  7. […]     This is a very well-researched and comprehensive look at how the GOP has misread the results of the November election debacle. (Oh yeah… and she cites this blog.) They are trying to spend political capital that they simply don’t have. It’s also why I firmly believe their majority will be very short-lived, Barak Obama is a shoe-in in 2012, and our economy is going to Hell in a handbasket.      Politicians these days represent narrow interests and are deliberately misrepresenting recent election results as support for policies not presented to the general electorate during their campaigns. Some of this agenda may have been possibly inkled to their extremists supporters through code words, but from the looks of polls, most of it appears to have come as a complete surprise to their electorate.  This is probably because people generally don … Read More […]

  8. janicen says:

    Apparently, Boehner isn’t crazy enough for the Tea Party, and they want him gone…

  9. Minkoff Minx says:

    Oh wow, Dak this is a great post. This is something that needs to be brought to the attention of those who are steadfast in their beliefs that labor unions are a bad thing.